The Reluctant Missionary

Authentic stories from the travels of Michael Smalley.

Why Your Body Remembers What Your Mind Wants to Forget

trauma Sep 14, 2025

 

The hidden reason talk therapy isn't enough—and why healing trauma requires more than just changing your thoughts


"I've done years of therapy," Lisa told me during our first session. "I've processed my childhood, I understand my patterns, I can explain exactly why I react the way I do. But I still feel stuck. My body still goes into panic mode over the smallest things."

She paused, frustrated. "I feel like I should be better by now. I mean, I know better. So why doesn't my body seem to know that?"

Lisa had discovered what millions of trauma survivors learn the hard way: your mind can understand what happened to you, but your body remembers what it felt like to almost die.

This realization hit me personally when I started working with a trauma specialist named Lilly. As we explored my own patterns of shutdown and hypervigilance, she asked me something that stopped me cold:

"Michael, tell me about the times in your life when you thought you might not survive."

I started rattling off what I considered the "big" traumas—relationship conflicts, career setbacks, emotional wounds. But she meant something else entirely.

"No," she said gently. "Tell me about the times your body literally thought it was going to die."

That's when I realized my body had been keeping score of things my mind had forgotten—or never fully processed.

The Body's Trauma Resume

At three weeks old, I nearly died from dehydration and starvation due to projectile vomiting that my parents didn't realize was a serious medical condition. The surgeon told them I probably wouldn't survive the operation.

At four, I drowned in a Holiday Inn pool and had to be revived.

At thirteen, I was in a horrific car accident that a local rock station voted "worst wreck of the week."

At eighteen, I drowned again—caught in a massive eddy on the Guadalupe River in Texas while eight people had died in the same spot days earlier.

At nineteen, I fell thirty feet while rock climbing at Enchanted Rock.

In 2003, I became one of the only living kidney donors to flatline during surgery. What was supposed to be a 1.5-hour procedure turned into a 6-hour life-saving operation.

My mind had filed these away as "things that happened." My body had filed them away as "times we almost died and need to stay ready for the next threat."

For decades, I couldn't understand why I was constantly hypervigilant, why I struggled, why my nervous system seemed to operate at such a high baseline of activation.

I was treating the symptoms with my mind while ignoring the fact that my body was still in survival mode from experiences that happened decades earlier.

The Science Your Body Keeps

Here's what most people don't understand about trauma: it doesn't just get stored in your memory. It gets stored in your cells.

When you experience a life-threatening event, your body releases a cascade of stress hormones—adrenaline, cortisol, norepinephrine. These chemicals are designed to help you survive immediate danger by:

  • Increasing heart rate and blood pressure
  • Flooding muscles with energy
  • Heightening awareness and reflexes
  • Suppressing non-essential functions like digestion

This is perfect if you're being chased by a bear. It's devastating if your nervous system stays activated long after the danger has passed.

Research from experts like Dr. Bessel van der Kolk shows that trauma literally changes your brain structure and nervous system functioning. The parts of your brain responsible for rational thinking (prefrontal cortex) go offline, while the survival centers (amygdala and brain stem) take over.

Your body develops a hair-trigger response to anything that remotely resembles past danger—even when your rational mind knows you're safe.

This is why you can intellectually understand that your partner's tone of voice isn't actually threatening, but your body still floods with fight-or-flight chemicals.

Your mind says "we're safe." Your body says "we've heard that before."

When Your Body Becomes the Problem

Clients often come to me frustrated because traditional therapy helped them understand their trauma but didn't stop their trauma responses.

They can explain their triggers. They understand their family patterns. They've gained insight into their defense mechanisms.

But their bodies are still reacting as if the original trauma is happening right now.

This shows up as:

  • Panic attacks seemingly "out of nowhere"
  • Chronic muscle tension or pain
  • Sleep disturbances and hypervigilance
  • Digestive issues and autoimmune problems
  • Difficulty regulating emotions or feeling numb
  • Being startled easily or constantly "on edge"
  • Physical reactions during intimacy or conflict

Traditional talk therapy works with the mind. But trauma lives in the body.

The Breathing Revolution

Working with Lilly, I discovered something that changed everything: the power of conscious breathing to rewire my nervous system literally.

For most of my life, I had been a shallow breather—taking quick, chest-level breaths that kept my body in a constant state of low-level activation.

Lilly taught me that breath is the bridge between your conscious mind and your autonomic nervous system. It's the one function that's both automatic and under your voluntary control.

Through specific breathing techniques, I learned to:

  • Send signals of safety to my nervous system
  • Activate my parasympathetic (rest and digest) response
  • Stay present in my body instead of dissociating
  • Interrupt panic responses before they took over

For the first time in decades, my body began to believe that it was actually safe.

One session stood out, as I worked on staying present in my body through mindful breathing. That's when I had a life-changing encounter with God. I heard Him speak clearly, and those words became the foundation of my healing: "I am enough. And you are enough." It was like God was right there with me, reminding me that He's all I need. But the second revelation was just as powerful: I was enough too. He loved me just as I am.

That moment of divine encounter happened not just in my mind, but in my body. I felt the truth settle into my cells in a way that purely intellectual understanding never could.

Beyond Talk Therapy: Body-Based Healing

If traditional therapy helped you understand your trauma but you still feel physically stuck, you're not broken. You just need approaches that work with your nervous system, not just your thoughts.

Body-based trauma therapies include:

Somatic Experiencing: Focuses on releasing trapped survival energy from your nervous system

EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing): Uses bilateral stimulation to help process traumatic memories

Internal Family Systems (IFS): Works with different parts of your psyche, including those that hold trauma in the body

Breathwork and Nervous System Regulation: Teaches your body new patterns of activation and calm

Body-oriented therapies: Include massage, yoga, movement therapy, and other approaches that work directly with physical tension and activation

The key insight: these approaches don't just help you think differently about your trauma. They help your body learn that the trauma is over.

The 5-4-3-2-1 Technique: Bringing Your Body Back to Safety

When you feel your nervous system starting to activate, try this grounding technique:

5 things you can see around you right now
4 things you can physically touch
3 things you can hear
2 things you can smell
1 thing you can taste

This technique works because it brings you back into your body and into the present moment, interrupting the trauma response that's trying to convince your body you're back in the original danger.

The key is willingness—willingness to be aware of how your body is responding, and willingness to try something different instead of relying on strategies that have never actually worked.

Your Body Wants to Heal

Here's the beautiful truth about your nervous system: it wants to return to balance.

Your body isn't broken or defective because it holds trauma responses. It's actually working perfectly, trying to protect you based on the information it has.

The hypervigilance that exhausts you? It kept you alive during actual danger.

The muscle tension that causes you pain? It prepared your body to fight or flee when fighting or fleeing were necessary.

The shallow breathing that keeps you anxious? It gave you quick energy during life-threatening situations.

Your body doesn't need to be fixed. It needs to be updated with the information that the danger has passed.

Healing Happens in Layers

Body-based trauma healing doesn't happen overnight. Your nervous system has been practicing these survival responses for years or decades. It takes time to learn new patterns.

But unlike purely cognitive approaches, somatic healing creates lasting change because it works with your body's natural healing capacity.

You begin to feel safe in your own skin. Your nervous system learns to distinguish between past danger and present safety. Your body becomes a place of refuge instead of a source of anxiety.

You Don't Have to Stay Stuck

If you've done traditional therapy but still feel physically activated, if your body seems to have a mind of its own when it comes to trauma responses, if you're tired of understanding your patterns intellectually but still being controlled by them physically—there's hope.

Your body remembers what your mind wants to forget, but it can also learn what your mind wants to teach it: that you're safe now.

This requires specialized, body-informed trauma work that goes beyond talk therapy. It requires approaches that honor both your mind's need to understand and your body's need to discharge trapped survival energy.

This is exactly why my personal coaching approach integrates both psychological insight and nervous system regulation.

In our work together, we'll:

  • Identify where trauma is stored in your body and nervous system
  • Learn practical tools for regulating your activation in real-time
  • Address both the psychological and somatic aspects of your healing
  • Help your body learn new patterns of safety and connection
  • Integrate breathing techniques and grounding practices into your daily life

Healing doesn't have to stay stuck in your head. Your body is ready to remember what safety feels like.

Ready to Heal Beyond Your Mind?

If you're ready to address trauma where it actually lives—in your nervous system and body—if you want to finally feel as safe as you know you actually are, I want to personally help you explore body-based healing approaches.

I'm offering free 30-minute consultations where we can discuss whether somatic approaches might be the missing piece in your healing journey.

This isn't about replacing the mental work you've done. This is about completing it by including your body in the healing process.

Your trauma happened in your body. Your healing can happen there too.


Take Action Today

Ready to bring your body into your healing journey?

  1. Practice the 5-4-3-2-1 technique when you feel activation starting
  2. Notice your breathing throughout the day—are you taking shallow, chest breaths or deeper belly breaths?
  3. Schedule a consultation to explore body-based approaches to trauma healing

SCHEDULE YOUR FREE CONSULTATION →


Remember: Your body isn't broken because it holds trauma responses. It's working perfectly to protect you based on old information. With body-informed approaches, you can update that information and finally feel as safe as you actually are.

What clicked for you about the connection between trauma and your body? Share in the comments—your insight might help someone else realize why traditional therapy alone hasn't been enough for their healing journey.

IT WORKS IF YOU WORK IT

Live Virtual Coaching!

Get access to 9 live virtual coaching sessions every month with Dr. Michael Smalley through the VIP Inner Circle membership. You'll have 24/7 digital access to his coaching, a growing video library, tools to improve your communication and intimacy, assessments to guide you on your path to healing, and a supportive community of people who will encourage you as you work toward the relationship you desire.

Learn More